Yeah, I agree with you on Tebow. Overrated by who? There was a very small % of media that loved him(Skip Bayless), some that absolutely hated him, and most just stated the fact that despite his immense popularity & charisma, he was limited in skills, and not a long term answer.

Their definition of overrated is a bit off base.

Why does Osweiler have a Broncos logo? It was the Texans that overrated him, and he played for the Dolphins the most recently.

Terrible list

Can’t imagine a worse application of ChatGPT than something like this.

Most overrated Lamar Jackson

Tebow did NOT take us to a championship game.

Ironically, you're over-rating him with that statement ; )

I’d take Tebow over Russ

I think someone here made this list. So who hated Cutler and Tebow here?

#1. Kyle Slotter

Kudos, exactly what I was going to say.

As QB's, I did. I don't like some of the rankings but overall I agree with the list. I've seen other lists out there for the best QB's, like 2000 to 2010, and it goes to show how few really good QB's there have been. Amazingly Cutler was on that list. He was a narcissist and threw his teammates under the bus. Could not admit his own fallacies. Tebow just wasn't a QB.

Russ is

Perfect example of why Tebow is the most overrated QB.

7 wins in 2011, 0 wins 2012-22. Russ has 108 wins 2012-22.

”But, but Tebow wasn’t given a chance…”

Yeah, that is what I was thinking. Overhyped.... probably would be a better word to describe this list. But overrated... the general consensus is that almost all of these qbs were generally considered subpar to terrible.

If it was 2011, this list made more sense. After tebow flopped with eagirls it was over.

BRONCOS HAVE 3 PLAYERS!!!

5 actually:

Tebow
Sanchez
Cutler
Bortles
Osweiler

No Johnny Manziel on that list? totally bogus.

Literally the stupidest list I have EVER seen.


Rex Grossman was a MONSTER in 2007 (08?), went 13-3, took the Bears to the Super Bowl. If this list was 100 QBs long, he'd still not belong.

Colin Kaepernick took over the 49ers mid-season 2012, led them to the Super Bowl, losing by a field goal. Next year led 'em to 12 -4 and the Seattle 18 with 30 seconds left on the road in the NFCCG. Colin "shouldn't'a tried him with a sorry receiver like Crabtree," but he shouldn't'a been on this list neither.

Andy Dalton has a career record of 83-77, most of it with the uber-champion under-achiever Cincinnati Bengals. And you? You have a career "List-Maker Moron" record of 100%

Tim Tebow took over a 1-4 team mid-season, and in the greatest display of over-achievement in the face of limited skills, chalked up six 4th qtr comebacks, six GW drives, 4 OT wins, a division title, a playoff victory and the most exciting play in Denver Broncos history. All in a season so magical that Saturday Night Live did a skit about it. He never won another game, but that season alone excludes him from this list. With prejudice.

Jay Cutler is a boring low-key blob, but he's also the all-time leading passer for the Chicago Bears. Holds most every franchise passing record. Only a moron would see fit to put him on this list.

Brock Osweiler is a self-centered anti-social ne'er do well, but he stepped in and went 5-2 with a critical OT win over the Patriots, setting up one of the all-time greats for a storybook career finish. Maybe Brock​ for the Top 25 list, but not this one.

Matt Cassel wasn't horrible, and should rightly be a proud 7th round draft pick who played 14 years. NO LIST FOR MATT!

Sam Bradford wasn't great, neither were Blake Bottles or Mark Sanchez. But each of them had a bright spot or two, and all three can look down their noses at every guy on the list directly below .....


HEY LIST-MAKER MORON! ..... Jake Locker, Akili Smith, ​
Johnny Manziel, Christian Ponder, Cade McNown, ​​​JaMarcus Russell,​
Dwayne Haskins, Christian Hackenberg, ​Joey Harrington, Sam Darnold,
Mitchell Trubisky, Jimmy Clausen, Josh Freeman, Matt Leinert, Paxton
Lynch, Brady Quinn, Quincy Carter, Giovanni Carmazzi
​

The list-maker moron was AI.